Second Edition, Quatrain LXIII
Why, be this Juice the growth of God, who dare
Blaspheme the twisted tendril as a Snare?
A Blessing, we should use it, should we not?
And if a Curse--why, then, Who set it there?
Fifth Edition, Quatrain LXI
Why, be this Juice the growth of God, who dare
Blaspheme the twisted tendril as a Snare?
A Blessing, we should use it, should we not?
And if a Curse--why, then, Who set it there?
I see no differences between the Second and the Fifth Editions.
This is probably one of the quatrains that caused Khayyam to be attacked and reviled as a heretic and destined for eternal damnation by religious authorities. Wine, of course, was forbidden the faithful as the handiwork of Satan, and, in this quatrain, Khayyam not only defends drinking wine and calls it "A Blessing" but insists God, not Satan, created it.
If Allah created everything, that must include grape vines, so how could that be bad or evil? Would God create something evil? I have read attempts to defend Khayyam from the charges of heresy by insisting that he really didn't mean wine at all. When Khayyam refers to wine, he really means God's grace! What is never explained is why Khayyam didn't simply refer to God's grace and, instead, substituted something forbidden, something condemned as evil for God's grace.
There are some quatrains where this interpretation could work, but there are too many where it makes no sense at all. And in this quatrain, it doesn't even come close to being reasonable for I don't see how one could argue that Khayyam really meant God's grace.
0 Yorumlar